Your area Not set — showing everywhere
Meeting report · Selectboard
Creating this report cost real money. Help fund coverage →

Selectboard — March 16, 2026

The meeting was largely procedural and collegial but carried underlying tension around recruitment failures, a pointed public complaint about hiring practices, frank acknowledgment that the town's hostile public climate deters staff, and an unscheduled but significant discussion of ambulance service gaps — all of which suggest real institutional stress beneath a unified surface.

Date Monday, March 16, 2026 Duration 2.6h Speakers 5 Public comments 2 Decisions 13 Lively

Public ⁠impact

Issues from this meeting with documented community impact.
01

2026 Municipal Tax Rate Increase

Municipal rate rising from $2.71 to $3.00 per thousand; $116 annual increase on a $400,000 home, up to $435 on a $1.5 million home Affected: All Sunapee property owners
tax increase
02

Ambulance Service Cost and Potential Service Change

$67,000+ annual cost to New London Hospital; upcoming service changes may force the town to create its own ambulance service, with significant budget and safety implications Affected: All Sunapee residents requiring emergency medical services
safety change
03

Hydroelectric Plant Revenue Loss

Revenue dropped to approximately $17,000 per check from historically higher contract returns; long-term fiscal gap requiring replacement through taxes or cuts Affected: All taxpayers relying on non-tax revenue to offset property tax rates
other high impact
04

Multiple Critical Staff Vacancies Affecting Municipal Services

Five or more critical positions vacant simultaneously including fire chief, code compliance officer, heavy equipment operator, and police officer Affected: All residents dependent on code enforcement, public works, highway maintenance, police, and fire services
service reduction

Decisions ⁠logged

Every recorded vote, with timestamps and dissents.
Approved March 2nd meeting minutes
Motion made, seconded, and approved without discussion
Unanimous approval
Approved 2026 pay table with 3% COLA increase
Motion approved with amendment to place fire chief position at Grade 18
Approved with amendment
Elected Anthony as Selectboard Chair and Jeremy as Vice Chair
Anthony nominated for chair, Jeremy for vice chair, after Fred declined due to work schedule constraints
Unanimous approval
Appointed Sue to Advisory Budget Committee
Motion made and seconded to appoint Sue to ABC committee
Unanimous approval
Appointed Jeremy to Crother Chapel Committee
Jeremy agreed to continue serving on this committee
Unanimous approval
Appointed Fred to Highway Safety Committee
Fred agreed to continue despite winter scheduling challenges
Unanimous approval
Appointed Aaron to Planning Board as Selectboard representative
Continuation of Aaron's existing role on Planning Board
Unanimous approval
Appointed David to School Advisory Budget Committee
New appointment after uncertainty about previous representative
Unanimous approval
Approved items for signature including solar exemption, timber cuts, and check manifest totaling $111,024.19
Updated amount provided by Shannon after review and certification
Unanimous approval
Approved acceptance of $173.10 in gift cards for Food Pantry
Unanticipated revenue in form of gift cards received before new donation policy vote
Unanimous approval
Approved sale of 1994 fire truck to A.P. Howard Sales
Sale price of $17,257, chosen over competing bid of $444.87. Truck had 19,000 miles and approximately 1,600-1,700 engine hours.
Unanimous approval
Motion to enter non-public session
Under RSA 91-A:3(a) for dismissal, promotion or compensation matters
Approved via roll call vote
Scheduled priority-setting work session for March 23rd at 9:30 AM
3-hour working meeting to discuss priorities, ending by 12:30 PM for Fred's appointment
Unanimous agreement

Topics ⁠discussed

Click a topic to expand quotes and full context.
▶ 02:18 Meeting Opening and March 2nd Minutes Approval

Meeting called to order on March 16, 2026 with pledge of allegiance. March 2nd meeting minutes were reviewed and approved unanimously.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 03:17 Welcome to New Board Member David Andrews

Board welcomed newly elected selectboard member David Andrews and thanked election volunteers and staff for their work.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 03:35 Board Member Orientation and Resource Materials

Town Manager provided orientation materials including 'Knowing the Territory' guidebook and Right to Know manual to new board members, explaining key governance rules and communication restrictions.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 06:04 Right to Know Request Process and Burden

Extensive discussion of Right to Know law requirements, processing burden on staff (averaging 2 requests per week), and policy of requiring in-person record review rather than electronic delivery for formal requests.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 20:24 Policy and Procedures Review

Board directed to review policies and procedures document by next meeting, with specific attention to agenda format changes and potential move of board member reports to earlier in meetings for more discussion.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 28:08 Public Comment Format Discussion

Discussion of potentially changing public comment from 3 to 5 minutes and allowing board responses, with concerns raised about speaking without complete information.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 36:29 Staffing Vacancies and Organizational Challenges

Town Manager outlined multiple vacant positions including code compliance officer, buildings/grounds foreman, heavy equipment operator, police officer, and fire chief, noting recruitment difficulties.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 54:05 2026 Pay Table Approval

Board reviewed and approved 2026 pay table with 3% COLA increase, including amendment to place fire chief at Grade 18.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:03:52 Organizational Management and Staffing Needs

Town Manager discussed need for comprehensive organizational study to determine if current positions are fit for purpose, including potential for technology integration, urban planning needs, and project management capabilities.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:08:01 Investment and Fund Policy Compliance

Town Manager reported the need to reaffirm investment policy annually for audit compliance, noting they were previously dinged for not reaffirming the policy.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:09:01 Upcoming Policy Reviews and Calendar Items

Discussion of multiple policies needing review including recreation ordinance, right-to-know policy, ethics policy, financial disclosure policy, and alcohol policy, with various scheduled items through summer.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:22:01 Selectboard Leadership Elections

Board conducted annual election of chair and vice chair positions, with nominations and discussion of candidates' availability and commitment.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:33:11 Committee Appointments

Board made various committee and board appointments including ABC Committee, Energy Aggregation, Highway Safety, Planning Board representative, and others.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:44:36 Public Comments on Hiring Practices

Resident criticized town's hiring response time for heavy equipment operator position, citing poor communication as deterrent to applicants.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:57:37 2026 Budget Analysis and Tax Impact

Town Manager provided detailed breakdown of approved 2026 budget including warrant articles and encumbrances, with estimated tax rate impacts for various property values.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 2:06:20 Municipal Tax Rate Impact Discussion

Board discussed estimated tax rate increases for 2026, with municipal portion going from $2.71 to $3.00 per thousand, resulting in increases of $79.75 for a $275,000 home up to $435 for a $1.5 million home.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 2:14:55 Hydro Plant Revenue Discussion

Discussion of hydroelectric plant's reduced profitability due to expired long-term contract and current market rates, with recent check of only $17,000 compared to historical higher returns.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 2:16:52 Fire Truck Sale Approval

Board approved sale of 1994 fire truck to A.P. Howard Sales for $17,257 after receiving two bids (the other being $444.87).

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 2:21:42 Boring Holes Project on Lake Avenue

Town manager announced boring polls will be conducted on Lake Avenue in late March as part of ongoing infrastructure study, with coordination among departments and public notification planned.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 2:26:44 Election Process Review

Board members discussed performance of new voting tabulation machine, noting it processed 900+ votes with 31% turnout but created longer lines due to thorough overvote detection.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 2:34:52 Ambulance Service Discussion

Board member raised need for town ambulance service given $67,000+ annual cost to London Hospital and upcoming service changes, suggesting integration with new fire chief hiring.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker

Controversy & ⁠dissent

Where the board, the community, or the agenda diverged.

Potentially controversial issues

01

Municipal Tax Rate Increase for 2026

The municipal portion of the tax rate is rising from $2.71 to $3.00 per thousand, translating to increases of $116–$435 annually depending on property value. Residents on fixed incomes or with modest properties will feel the pinch, and the Town Manager's attempt to contextualize the increase ('a pair of shoes, a night out') could be perceived as dismissive of real financial hardship.
Board position: Board accepted the budget outcomes and the resulting tax rate increase without seeking further reductions.
medium concern
02

Chronic Staff Vacancies and Recruitment Crisis

The Town Manager acknowledged multiple critical open positions (code compliance, buildings/grounds foreman, heavy equipment operator, police officer, fire chief) and directly stated that the town's combative public environment deters candidates — 'people see how oftentimes you can get annihilated here.' A resident publicly criticized poor hiring communication, suggesting the town is losing applicants through process failures. This affects service delivery for all residents.
Board position: Board acknowledged the problem and asked the Town Manager to improve applicant communication and produce a color-coded org chart of vacancies, but no concrete hiring timeline was set.
medium concern
03

Hiring Process Communication Failure (Heavy Equipment Operator)

A resident (Cindy Spear) appeared at public comment to criticize how a specific job applicant was treated — placed on a short list, never contacted back despite follow-up emails. This is a concrete, named complaint about governance competence that affects the town's ability to fill critical vacancies.
Board position: Town Manager defended the process, citing unreadable application documents and her own leave absence as contributing factors, and committed to creating better applicant communication tools.
medium concern
04

Ambulance Service Gap and $67,000 Annual Cost to New London Hospital

A board member raised the fact that the town is paying over $67,000 annually to New London Hospital for ambulance service, and that upcoming service changes may force the issue. With the majority of fire department calls being medical, this is a significant public safety and budget concern that has not been formally placed on the agenda or studied. Connects to the existing tracked issue around the New London Hospital lease.
Board position: Raised by a speaker as a concern to integrate into the fire chief hiring process; no formal action taken or scheduled.
medium concern
05

Right to Know Request Burden and In-Person Review Policy

The board discussed a policy of requiring in-person record review rather than electronic delivery for formal Right to Know requests, framed in part as a workload management tool given ~2 requests per week. Critics could argue this creates barriers to public transparency and access, particularly for residents who cannot easily come in person.
Board position: Board appeared supportive of maintaining the in-person review policy as a way to manage staff burden.
low concern
06

Hydroelectric Plant Revenue Collapse

The hydroelectric plant's long-term contract has expired and a recent revenue check was only $17,000 — dramatically below historical returns. This is a significant loss of non-tax revenue the town has historically relied upon and has direct budget implications for future tax rates. a speaker expressed frustration about the loss of this income stream alongside county and donor-town tax obligations.
Board position: Board noted the situation but took no action; treated as background financial context.
medium concern
07

County Tax and Donor Town Funding Formula Frustration

a speaker made pointed remarks about the town 'sacrificing talent to support other things we get very little back out of,' specifically calling out county taxes and the donor town education funding formula as money sent away with no local benefit. This reflects long-simmering frustration with state-level fiscal structures that constrain local budgets, connecting to the previously tracked HB1800/1787 issue.
Board position: No formal position taken; raised as context during budget discussion without action.
medium concern

Community vs. board tension

Action ⁠items

Who owes what, by when.
Review policies and procedures document and come prepared to discuss changes at next meeting
Assigned: Board Members · Due: April 6th meeting
Provide color-coded org chart showing open positions and priority rankings
Assigned: a speaker (Town Manager) · Due: Next meeting
Obtain and share Hanover's board governance policies as example
Assigned: a speaker (Town Manager) · Due: Not specified
Sign up for local officials workshop on April 22nd
Assigned: a speaker (David Andrews) · Due: Before April 22nd
Draft RFP for Capital Improvement Program Committee
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: End of March
Provide updated financial disclosure policy for next meeting
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Next meeting
Send calendar invites for March 23rd work session
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: ASAP
Continue conversation with Dave Hoffman about River Walk documentation
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Before May meeting
Develop scope of work for parking study
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Ongoing
Create FAQ or process documentation for job applicants
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Not specified
Coordinate boring holes project on Lake Avenue with water/sewer, highway, and police departments and notify public
Assigned: Town Manager (a speaker) · Due: Last week of March
Continue discussions on housing challenges and harbor issues
Assigned: Board · Due: Meeting on March 23rd

Notable ⁠statements

I think people see how oftentimes you can get annihilated here and it doesn't feel good and it doesn't feel comfortable. And so people don't want to participate. — Speaker D (Town Manager) · Explaining why the town has difficulty recruiting and retaining employees ▶ 36:29
We need somebody who can do true project management and who understands how to work with people, how to bring people together, how to convene people so that we then get that we're moving things forward because we're stagnant on a number of different things. — Speaker D (Town Manager) · Describing staffing needs beyond just an executive assistant ▶ 1:05:04
I don't want to see us open ourselves up to a blindsiding situation where we just simply don't have the answers to, to be able to comment appropriately on what's been said. — Unidentified speaker · Expressing caution about responding to public comments without complete information ▶ 29:44
Every single one of my staff members are working incredibly hard because we all believe in providing better services, the best service that we're able to provide to our residents. They deeply, deeply care about this community. — Speaker D (Town Manager) · Defending town employees against criticism and emphasizing their dedication ▶ 1:16:33
I'm very hesitant to do it now because of my work schedule. I don't feel it would be appropriate for me to be in a chair or vice chair position because of the volatility of that. — Speaker B (Fred) · Explaining decision to decline leadership roles due to work commitments ▶ 1:23:58
We can't have all things at all times. Like we have to again have what are the priorities and how do we meet there and then how do we talk as a team about the things that we need in place. — Speaker D (Town Manager) · Responding to criticism about hiring process delays while defending staffing limitations ▶ 1:56:33
I understand that money is tight for everybody... $116 is a lot of money. It's a pair of shoes, it's a night out, it's tank of gas... But I also just want to put it in context of what it actually is. — Unidentified speaker · Explaining municipal tax increase impact to provide perspective on budget increases ▶ 2:06:20
The sad part of it is we're sacrificing our talent to support other things that we get very little back out of... especially at the county... And the donor town situation is money we send away and get absolutely no benefit out of it. — Unidentified speaker · Discussing frustration with county taxes and state education funding formula ▶ 2:12:03
We just spent 67 grand to the London Hospital's ambulance service this year... I think we need an ambulance in town... If you look at the service calls for the fire department, the vast majority are medical. — Unidentified speaker

Member ⁠positions

12 issues · 1 explicit · 22 inferred
Present
March 2nd Minutes Approval YES ~
2026 Pay Table Approval YES ~
Supported approval with fire chief at Grade 18 amendment
Selectboard Leadership Elections YES ~
Supported Anthony Dolan as Chair, Jeremy Hathorn as Vice Chair
Appointed Sue to Advisory Budget Committee YES
Accepted appointment to ABC Committee
Fire Truck Sale Approval YES ~
Public Comment Format Discussion
Engaged in discussion about extending public comment time and allowing board responses
Right to Know Request Burden and In-Person Review Policy ~
Appeared supportive of in-person review policy to manage staff burden
Ambulance Service Discussion
Raised $67,000 ambulance cost concern; advocated integrating issue into fire chief hiring
Jeremy Hathorn
Vice Chair
Present
March 2nd Minutes Approval YES ~
2026 Pay Table Approval YES ~
Selectboard Leadership Elections YES
Accepted Vice Chair nomination; declined Chair due to unspecified constraints
Appointed Jeremy to Crother Chapel Committee YES
Agreed to continue serving on committee
Public Comment Format Discussion
Cautious about board responding without complete information
Hydroelectric Plant Revenue Discussion
Expressed frustration at reduced hydro revenue and county/donor town tax obligations
Fire Truck Sale Approval YES ~
Selectboard Leadership Elections — declined Chair
Hesitant about chair/vice chair due to work schedule volatility
Anthony Dolan
Chair (elected this meeting)
Present
March 2nd Minutes Approval YES ~
2026 Pay Table Approval YES ~
Selectboard Leadership Elections YES
Nominated and elected as Chair
Fire Truck Sale Approval YES ~
Ambulance Service Discussion
Raised need for town ambulance service integrated with fire chief hiring
Frederick Gallup
Board Member
Present
March 2nd Minutes Approval YES ~
2026 Pay Table Approval YES ~
Selectboard Leadership Elections YES
Declined chair/vice chair due to work schedule; voted for Anthony and Jeremy
Appointed Fred to Highway Safety Committee YES
Agreed to continue despite winter scheduling challenges
Fire Truck Sale Approval YES ~
Priority-setting work session scheduling YES
Agreed to March 23rd work session ending by 12:30 PM for his appointment
Aaron Whipple
Board Member
Present
March 2nd Minutes Approval YES ~
2026 Pay Table Approval YES ~
Selectboard Leadership Elections YES ~
Supported Anthony as Chair and Jeremy as Vice Chair
Appointed Aaron to Planning Board as Selectboard representative YES
Continued existing role on Planning Board
Fire Truck Sale Approval YES ~

Positions marked ~ are inferred from context and may not reflect the member's explicitly stated position. UNCLEAR means the vote was split but the record did not name how this member voted — it is not a “yes.”

Public ⁠comment

What residents said — verbatim, with timestamps.
2
Total speakers
2
Addressed
0
Partial
0
Not addressed
Lisa
Addressed
Lisa congratulated the new board leadership and expressed support for collaborative work on housing between the select board and planning board. She requested changes to the public comment process to allow for board feedback, suggesting either board discussion immediately after comments or extending comment time to 5 minutes with board response time. Key concern
Lack of feedback from the board during public comments - residents ask questions or make suggestions but receive no response or acknowledgment
Board response
The board had already been discussing this issue earlier in the meeting and acknowledged her feedback positively, with a speaker thanking her
The board had already been discussing public comment format changes earlier in the meeting and positively acknowledged her input, indicating they were already working on this concern
Cindy Spear
Addressed
Cindy Spear from 146 Bradford complained about poor hiring practices, specifically citing someone who applied for heavy equipment operator position, was told they were on a short list, but never heard back despite multiple follow-up emails. She argued this poor communication drives potential employees away and hurts the town's reputation. Key concern
Poor communication and follow-up during hiring processes is causing the town to lose potential employees
Board response
Town Manager Shannon Dantru provided a detailed explanation of the hiring process, noting the applicant had submitted unreadable documents initially, required resubmission, and that she had responded while on leave. She explained the standard process of keeping positions open for set periods before beginning interviews.
The town manager provided a comprehensive response explaining the specific situation and the standard hiring process, directly addressing the concern about communication

Accountability ⁠flags

Documented procedural gaps. Each item links to its source.

Agenda items not discussed

Support coverage

Creating this report cost ⁠real money.

MeetingWatch attended, transcribed, and analyzed this meeting on its own dime. If this work is valuable to you, chip in to keep covering Sunapee.

Report composed by claude-sonnet-4-20250514, claude-sonnet-4-6, claude-opus-4-6 · analyzed 2026-04-04.