Meeting report · Selectboard
Creating this report cost real money.
Help fund coverage →
Selectboard — August 18, 2025
The meeting was largely routine and collegial, but the unresolved harbor bridge legal ambiguity, off-agenda land purchase discussion with intra-board pushback, a partially unaddressed public concern about trucking enforcement, and disclosure of significant multi-department staffing shortages introduced enough friction and unresolved tension to lift the temperature above purely routine.
Public impact
Issues from this meeting with documented community impact.
01
Municipal Fee Schedule Increases — Land Use, Fire, Police, General Government
Broad fee increases across multiple town departments; after-the-fact permit violations now carry a minimum $400 fine plus original permit cost Affected: All residents and property owners who apply for building, land use, fire, or police-related permits or services
fee change
02
Deputy Police Chief Resignation and Multi-Position Staffing Vacancies
Simultaneous vacancies in Deputy Police Chief, compliance officer, part-time police officer, crossing guard, deputy assessor, and janitorial roles; staff covering multiple functions during shortage Affected: All Sunapee residents dependent on police, code compliance, and municipal services
safety change
Decisions logged
Every recorded vote, with timestamps and dissents.
Approved minutes from August 4th meeting
Motion made and seconded, all in favor
Unanimous approval
Approved items for signature including tax abatement and wedding blessing
Tax abatement for fire victims and Crowther Chapel blessing approved
Unanimous approval
Appointed Peter Macasik as alternate to Abbott Library Board of Trustees
Motion made by a speaker, seconded by a speaker
Unanimous approval
Appointed Catherine Bouchett as Community Power Representative
Motion made and seconded after discussion about Community Power status
Unanimous approval
Approved updated fee schedule as presented
Accepted land use, fire, police, and general government fee increases
Unanimous approval
Approved $43,475 for HVAC replacement at Safety Services building
Two condensing units and air handlers replacement from capital reserve
Unanimous approval
Approved $34,000 for three overhead doors at Highway Garage
Replacement of 23-year-old doors from capital reserve fund
Unanimous approval
Approved use of credit card reward points for staff appreciation gift cards
Motion to allow town manager to use credit card points to purchase $25 gift cards for employee appreciation day
Unanimous approval
Topics discussed
Click a topic to expand quotes and full context.
▶ 01:47 Meeting Opening and Minutes Approval
Selectboard called to order at 6:30pm on August 18, 2025, with pledge of allegiance and approval of August 4th minutes.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 02:39 Tax Abatement and Wedding Blessing Approval
Board approved tax abatement for house fire victims on Upper Bay Road and wedding blessing at Crowther Chapel by St. Joachim's Church.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 04:36 Board Appointments
Appointed Peter Macasik as alternate to Abbott Library Board of Trustees and Catherine Bouchett as Community Power Representative.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 06:15 Community Power Discussion
Board discussed Community Power program status, confirming they have not entered due to unfavorable rates and will only proceed if advantageous to taxpayers.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 16:29 Fee Schedule Public Hearing
Public hearing on amendments to town fee schedules for land use, fire department, police department, and general government services.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 39:15 Capital Reserve Fund Requests
Craig presented requests for HVAC replacement at Safety Services building ($43,475) and overhead doors at Highway Garage ($34,000).
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 49:32 Police Chief Report
Chief provided updates on truck enforcement (10 violations addressed), Bradford Road speed data (68,000 vehicles studied), and George Mills Harbor enforcement (21 tickets issued).
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 57:28 Town Manager Updates
Updates on Kirkland Pond project, cybersecurity initiatives, staff changes including new welfare director hire and Deputy Chief Dana Ramspot's resignation.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:05:32 Staffing Shortages and Recruitment
Town is recruiting for multiple positions including compliance officer, part-time police officer, crossing guard, deputy assessor, and janitorial services. Staff are covering multiple roles during this shortage period.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:05:32 Tri-Town Joint Board of Assessing 20th Anniversary
Town Manager praised the success of the 20-year partnership between Sunapee, Newbury, and New London for shared assessing services, highlighting cost savings and expertise benefits.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:12:04 Harbor Bridge Ownership and Alcohol Permits
Complex discussion about bridge ownership between private property and town easements, affecting whether alcohol can be carried across the bridge. Legal clarification needed.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:28:43 Staff Appreciation Event Gift Cards
Town Manager requested permission to use credit card reward points to purchase $25 gift cards for staff appreciation event.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:31:02 Land Purchase Considerations
Discussion about potential land purchases for parking, including a property near the harbor, and broader considerations about revenue generation and development planning.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 1:48:57 Infrastructure Updates
Highway department completed 14 culvert replacements on Jobs Creek and will begin ditching and brushing in September. Beach closures announced for end of season.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
Controversy & dissent
Where the board, the community, or the agenda diverged.
Potentially controversial issues
01
Town Fee Schedule Increases
The board approved increases across land use, fire, police, and general government fees affecting any resident or business that interacts with permitting or town services. The after-the-fact penalty structure (minimum $400 fine plus original permit cost) drew a public question, suggesting residents are unaware of or concerned about the enforcement consequences. Fees were raised without strong public opposition at this hearing, but the increases broadly affect property owners and developers.
Board position: Unanimously approved the updated fee schedule as presented, with a side action item to research tiered fees for large projects over 5,000 sq ft.
medium concern
02
Harbor Bridge Ownership and Alcohol Permit Ambiguity
The board discovered mid-meeting that the legal status of the harbor bridge — whether it is private property or town easement — is unresolved, which directly affects whether alcohol can be legally carried across it. This has implications for alcohol permit holders, businesses operating near the harbor, and public access rights. The issue was raised off-agenda, no legal opinion was available, and the matter was deferred to future research. Residents and business owners affected had no chance to prepare or attend with this topic in mind.
Board position: Deferred resolution; directed Town Manager and Police Chief to research bridge ownership and consult with interested property owners before the next meeting.
medium concern
03
Land Purchase Considerations Near Harbor
Discussion about acquiring private land near the harbor for parking touched on contested priorities: fiscal restraint versus infrastructure investment. a speaker explicitly pushed back, stating 'We don't have any money. I don't think we can buy any property,' signaling intra-board friction over whether the town can or should pursue land acquisition. This topic was raised off-agenda with no public notice, depriving residents of an opportunity to weigh in on a potentially significant expenditure.
Board position: No decision made; discussion was exploratory, but the Town Manager raised it for consideration alongside broader revenue and development planning.
Internal dissent
a speaker expressed clear skepticism about the town's financial capacity to pursue land purchases, contrasting with the Town Manager's more favorable framing of the opportunity.
medium concern
04
Staffing Shortages Across Multiple Departments
The town is simultaneously recruiting for five or more positions — compliance officer, part-time police officer, crossing guard, deputy assessor, and janitorial services — while the Deputy Police Chief has resigned. Existing staff are covering multiple roles. This raises public safety and service delivery concerns. The issue was disclosed but no concrete remediation timeline or contingency plan was discussed on the record.
Board position: Acknowledged the situation as a temporary shortage period; no emergency measures or compensation adjustments were discussed publicly.
medium concern
05
Harbor Area Business Concentration and Alcohol Licensing
Board Chair (a speaker) expressed concern about market saturation, noting six alcohol-serving establishments now operating in the harbor area and questioning whether all can financially survive. This signals potential future scrutiny of new alcohol permits in the area and raises questions about the town's role in shaping local business development. The comment was off-the-cuff and unresolved, leaving business owners and applicants uncertain about the board's appetite for additional licenses.
Board position: No formal position taken; concern expressed informally by the Board Chair without follow-up action.
low concern
06
Truck Enforcement Signage — Unresolved Public Request
Lisa (a speaker) raised a substantive concern that the Police Chief is personally spending too much time on truck enforcement on Maple Street and requested permanent signage as a systemic solution, including an update on previously discussed Brookhaven signs. The board acknowledged her thanks to the Chief but did not address her specific requests for sign funding or a timeline, leaving a recurring community concern unresolved.
Board position: No direct response to the signage request or Brookhaven sign update; the community speaker's concern was only partially addressed.
medium concern
Community vs. board tension
Ready to share? AI-written accountability posts about this meeting's controversies.
View posts →
Action items
Who owes what, by when.
Research tiered fee structure for projects over 5,000 square feet
Assigned: Allison Traber · Due: Future meeting (unspecified)
Schedule master plan public hearing presentation
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: August 21st at 6:30pm at Safety Services building
Coordinate HVAC and door installations with approved funding
Assigned: Craig · Due: Not specified
Meet with new welfare director to establish work schedule
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Thursday
Research bridge ownership question and consult with interested property owners
Assigned: Town Manager and Chief · Due: Before next meeting
Prepare budget calendar for next meeting
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Next meeting
Consider attending next Tri-Town Joint Board meeting
Assigned: Select Board members · Due: Next Tri-Town meeting (hosted by New London)
Notable statements
We have not discussed or entered into the Community Power claiming any minute, shape or form. And when it becomes something that begins to appear to be an advantage to the town as well as our taxpayers and so on, then we'll discuss whether or not we get into it. — Unidentified speaker · Explaining the board's position on Community Power program participation ▶ 06:40
What we see now is even 10 years ago for some of those projects where it was the first building of going from those cottages that you're kind of referencing to what they have now is now we're seeing the renovation of we're tearing that down and rebuilding that. — Unidentified speaker · Explaining increased complexity in land use permitting ▶ 23:21
I'd like to thank the voters for supporting this Capital reserve and the importance of having something like this. What is all these parts and pieces for the building. — Unidentified speaker · Thanking voters for building maintenance capital reserve fund support ▶ 49:11
This year marks the 20th anniversary of this brave decision that the three towns came together and made. And I thought it would be worthwhile just to take a minute and pause and recognize how well it has worked for the towns. — Unidentified speaker · Celebrating the Tri-Town Joint Board of Assessing partnership ▶ 1:06:25
This year marks the 20th anniversary of this brave decision that the three towns came together and made... I'd encourage us to really look through the lens of data analysis and watch how much this model has saved us. — Unidentified speaker · Praising the Tri-Town assessing partnership and advocating for its preservation ▶ 1:05:32
We don't have any money. I don't think we can buy any property if we don't have any money. We can't put signs up. How are we going to buy a poor thousand dollar piece of property? — Unidentified speaker · Responding to discussion about potential land purchases for parking ▶ 1:31:02
I get concerned about overextension... I keep wondering, are they all going to be able to survive? I keep looking at the fact that we now have 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 places within the harbor where you can drink beer or alcohol. — Unidentified speaker · Expressing concern about too many similar businesses in the harbor area ▶ 1:43:52
Member positions
14 issues · 0 explicit · 16 inferred
Suzanne Gottling
Present
Chair
Meeting Opening and Minutes Approval
YES
~
Tax Abatement and Wedding Blessing Approval
YES
~
Board Appointments
YES
~
Community Power Discussion
YES
~
Supported appointing Catherine Bouchett; aligned with cautious approach to Community Power.
Fee Schedule Public Hearing
YES
~
Capital Reserve Fund Requests
YES
~
Staff Appreciation Event Gift Cards
YES
~
Land Purchase Considerations Near Harbor
✓
Expressed concern about overextension; skeptical of harbor area business saturation.
Harbor Bridge Ownership and Alcohol Permits
~
Supported deferring to research; participated in discussion as presiding Chair.
Jeremy Hathorn
Present
Vice Chair
Meeting Opening and Minutes Approval
YES
~
Tax Abatement and Wedding Blessing Approval
YES
~
Board Appointments
YES
✓
Made motion to appoint Peter Macasik as alternate to Abbott Library Board.
Community Power Discussion
YES
✓
Explicitly stated board has not entered Community Power; will only proceed if advantageous.
Fee Schedule Public Hearing
YES
~
Capital Reserve Fund Requests
YES
~
Staff Appreciation Event Gift Cards
YES
~
Land Purchase Considerations Near Harbor
~
Participated in exploratory discussion; no strong position recorded.
Harbor Bridge Ownership and Alcohol Permits
~
Participated in discussion; supported deferring to legal research.
Tri-Town Joint Board of Assessing 20th Anniversary
~
Participated positively in recognizing the partnership's success.
Positions marked ~ are inferred from context and may not reflect the member's explicitly stated position.
Public comment
What residents said — verbatim, with timestamps.
2
Total speakers
3
Addressed
1
Partial
0
Not addressed
Lisa
Addressed
Lisa asked about after-the-fact fines for CZC permits, wondering if there are penalties when someone builds something without getting required permits first. She was curious about the fee structure and whether fines are imposed on top of permit fees.
Key concern
Understanding the penalty structure for after-the-fact permit applications
Board responseBoard members and staff explained the fee structure in detail - after-the-fact permits carry a minimum $400 fine (or double the original fee if higher) plus the original permit cost. They emphasized the importance of getting permits before starting projects.
Her question was thoroughly answered with detailed explanation of the penalty structure and examples
Patricia Collins
Addressed
Patricia Collins praised Allison Traber's work as the land use coordinator, saying she was instrumental in helping them navigate a two-year process to replace a garage. She described Allison as polite, knowledgeable, and always responsive to questions.
Key concern
Expressing gratitude for excellent customer service from town staff
Board responseThe board thanked Patricia and agreed that Allison is valuable to the town. Board Chair said they all likely agree with her assessment.
The board acknowledged and appreciated her positive feedback about staff performance
Patricia Collins
Addressed
Patricia Collins thanked Chief Cobb and the police department for placing a speed sign on Springfield Road, which helped slow traffic for pedestrians, cyclists, horseback riders, and wildlife. She also praised the recreation department for the successful Rock Bass Derby event.
Key concern
Expressing appreciation for police traffic enforcement efforts and recreation department events
Board responseBoard members thanked her for the feedback. There was light discussion about the wildlife in her area.
The board acknowledged her thanks and engaged in friendly conversation about her comments
Lisa
Partial
Lisa thanked Chief Cobb for his responsiveness to truck complaints on Maple Street but expressed concern that the chief is spending too much time on enforcement when he has more important duties. She requested signs to help mitigate the truck problem and asked for an update on Brookhaven signs.
Key concern
Need for no-through-trucking signs to reduce enforcement burden on police chief and improve traffic issues
Board responseBoard members thanked her for the feedback but did not provide specific responses about funding for signs or timeline for Brookhaven signs.
Her appreciation was acknowledged but her specific requests for sign updates and funding solutions were not directly addressed
Accountability flags
Documented procedural gaps. Each item links to its source.
Transcript vs. official minutes
Support coverage
Creating this report cost real money.
MeetingWatch attended, transcribed, and analyzed this meeting on its own dime. If this work is valuable to you, chip in to keep covering Sunapee.
Follow Sunapee
One email when a new report is published from the Selectboard — or one weekly digest.
Report composed by
claude-sonnet-4-20250514, claude-sonnet-4-6, claude-opus-4-6 · analyzed 2026-05-19.