Your area Not set — showing everywhere
Meeting report · Planning Board
Creating this report cost real money. Help fund coverage →

Planning Board — June 9, 2026

Salem Planning Board approves significant parking reduction for South Broadway facility based on applicant's operational promises.

The meeting featured a spirited debate regarding traffic data accuracy, operational restrictions, and frustration from one member regarding the readiness of staff reviews.

Date Tuesday, June 9, 2026 Duration 1.3h Speakers 13 Public comments 2 Decisions 2 Lively

Questions about this meeting? ⁠Just ask.

Ask MeetingWatch answers from this meeting’s report, transcript, and records — with linked sources.

Summary AI-generated to surface controversy & community impact without bias — always verify against the actual meeting before relying on it.

At the June 9 Planning Board meeting, a decision was made regarding 291 South Broadway that could impact traffic and parking patterns for South Broadway residents for years to come.

The Board approved a 'change of use' for the Funhouse Plaza site, transforming an 18,000-square-foot retail space into an athletic performance facility. However, the approval comes with a significant concession: the developer was granted a permit to provide only 236 parking spaces, despite the city's standard requirement of 408 spaces.

The justification for this massive reduction is based on the applicant's representation that the facility will operate via scheduled classes rather than as an 'open membership' gym. This means the lower parking demand is predicated on how the business chooses to operate, rather than the physical capacity of the site.

The meeting saw heated debate among board members. Some argued that the city should rely on real-world data through mandatory post-occupancy traffic studies, while others pushed to make such studies optional to reduce costs. While the Board ultimately imposed 11 conditions to mitigate impact—including a third-party traffic review—the decision relies heavily on the business maintaining specific operational constraints to prevent local congestion.

Jun 9, 2026 1.3h long 13 speakers 2 public comments 2 decisions Lively
Notable statements Drag to browse

“These issues don't get done ahead of time... If nothing isn't ready, this applicant shouldn't even be here tonight.”

— SPEAKER_09 (Paul Pelletier) · Expressing frustration with the lack of completed staff and engineering reviews prior to the public hearing. ▶ 30:24

“I don't wish to have conditions that manage our businesses because we are managing them so that this doesn't occur anyway.”

— SPEAKER_08 (Adam Abbas) · Arguing against the condition that the facility must be 'appointment only' and cannot have 'open gym' hours. ▶ 1:04:03

“The board at some point should review our site plan exemption criteria.”

— SPEAKER_10 (Mr. LaFontaine) · Discussing the difficulty of converting large spaces between uses under current rules. ▶ 1:09:50

“I'd almost like to flip it and say, don't have Steve Pernaugh review the memo. Let's do a post-occupancy, because that's real life at that point.”

— SPEAKER_06 (Mr. Jordan) · Suggesting that real-world operational data is more valuable than theoretical trip generation models. ▶ 1:15:18
This meeting — choose a section

Public ⁠impact

Issues from this meeting with documented community impact.
What was discussed

Reduction of 172 parking spaces below the standard requirement.

What happened

Approved the change of use and conditional use permit subject to 11 conditions, including a post-occupancy report and third-party traffic review.

Topics ⁠discussed

Each topic expands to quotes and full context.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
What was discussed

A public hearing regarding a change of use for an 18,000 square foot retail space into an athletic performance facility at 291 South Broadway.

What happened

The board approved the change of use and the conditional use permit (CUP) for reduced parking, subject to 11 specific conditions. The board clarified that the conditional use permit would essentially allow for the reduced parking amount based on the applicant's representations. The board did not reach a definitive conclusion but noted the need to review exemption criteria in the future. The board ultimately decided to maintain the conditions as proposed, which includes the consultant's ability to determine the scope and necessity of the report.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
What was discussed

A preliminary hearing for a two-lot subdivision at 8 Atkinson Road was scheduled but subsequently withdrawn.

What happened

The Planning Director reported the item had been withdrawn from the agenda.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
What was discussed

The board discussed the discrepancy between the required 408 parking spaces and the 236 spaces available on-site, focusing on whether a conditional use permit could justify the reduction.

What happened

The board clarified that the conditional use permit would essentially allow for the reduced parking amount based on the applicant's representations.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
What was discussed

A discussion regarding whether a future transition from the current use back to retail would require new Planning Board approval.

What happened

The board did not reach a definitive conclusion but noted the need to review exemption criteria in the future.

Speakers: Unidentified speaker
What was discussed

Board members debated whether to make the post-occupancy traffic study/monitoring report mandatory or conditional upon the recommendation of a third-party consultant.

What happened

The board ultimately decided to maintain the conditions as proposed, which includes the consultant's ability to determine the scope and necessity of the report.

Controversy & ⁠dissent

Where the board, the community, or the agenda diverged.

Potentially controversial issues

01

Funhouse Plaza Site Plan (291 South Broadway)

The proposal involves a significant reduction in parking spaces (from 408 required to 236 available) based on the applicant's promise to operate via scheduled classes rather than open gym use. This creates a conflict between business flexibility and municipal traffic/parking oversight.
Board position: Approved the change of use and reduced parking, but imposed 11 strict conditions to ensure the low-impact nature of the business is maintained.
Internal dissent
Board members disagreed on the methodology for traffic monitoring; Member Carlson favored making the study optional to save costs, while Member Jordan argued for a mandatory study to ensure real-world data accuracy.
medium concern

Community vs. board tension

Public ⁠comment

What residents said — verbatim, with timestamps.
2
Total speakers
1
Addressed
1
Partial
0
Not addressed
David Jordan
Addressed
Representing Funhouse Plaza LLC, he presented the plan for a change of use to an 18,000 square foot fitness facility. He provided a trip generation memo and parking counts to argue that the facility will not create parking issues and will actually generate fewer trips than a standard retail tenant. Key concern
Requesting a change of use and a conditional use permit for reduced parking based on anticipated low impact.
Board response
The board engaged in extensive discussion regarding the traffic study, parking requirements, and operational conditions.
The board ultimately moved toward approval of the change of use and the conditional use permit, albeit with specific conditions regarding traffic monitoring and landscaping.
Adam Abbas
Partial
The property manager expressed concerns regarding restrictive conditions placed on the business operations. He argued that the business model is intentionally low-impact to fit the site's needs and that the requirement for 'appointment only' classes could create legal and management issues. Key concern
Requesting the removal of restrictive operational conditions (appointment-only classes) and concerns regarding the delay caused by the third-party traffic review.
Board response
The board discussed the condition, with staff explaining that it serves to reinforce the applicant's own representations to ensure the site remains low-impact.
The board maintained the condition that all applicant representations (including no open gym) be incorporated into the approval, though they did agree to include a crosswalk as requested.

Decisions ⁠logged

Every recorded vote, with timestamps and dissents.
Accept the Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan as complete.
The board voted to accept the site plan for the 18,000 square foot fitness studio as complete.
Unanimous
Approve Funhouse Plaza LLC (291 South Broadway) for a change of use and a conditional use permit (CUP) for reduced parking.
The approval includes 11 conditions, including requirements for landscaping, ADA compliance, site improvements (striping/crosswalk), and submission of the third-party traffic review prior to occupancy. The motion by Mr. Pelletier was withdrawn and a new motion was made by Ms. Carlson. The 10 conditions include: 1) Staff/third-party traffic approval prior to permits, 2) construction per plan, 3) escrow for monitoring (scope determined by consultant if necessary), 4) landscaping maintenance, 5) as-built plans, 6) post-occupancy report (6-9 months), 7) approval required for increased traffic use, 8) notation of reduced parking/hours on plan, 9) no exceeding lot capacity, and 10) incorporation of all applicant representations.
Approved

Share ⁠this report

Drafts ready to post — click a block to copy, or use Share to post it.

X / Twitter — by angle

Significant reduction in parking requirements based on applicant promises
At the June 9 Planning Board meeting, officials approved a massive parking reduction for 291 South Broadway. The developer will provide only 236 spaces despite a 408-space requirement, relying on promises to limit business hours... https://meetingwatch.org/nh/salem/planning-board/2026-06-09/ #MeetingWatch #SalemNH
315/280 chars
Internal board division regarding evidence-based oversight
Salem Planning Board debate: Should traffic studies be mandatory or optional? On June 9, members split on whether to require real-world data or rely on theoretical predictions to manage traffic impacts at Funhouse Plaza on South... https://meetingwatch.org/nh/salem/planning-board/2026-06-09/ #MeetingWatch #SalemNH
315/280 chars
Inefficiency and lack of preparedness for public hearings
Frustration rose at the June 9 Planning Board meeting when members noted that critical staff and engineering reviews weren't finished before the public hearing. If the data isn't ready, should the hearing even happen? #SalemNH... https://meetingwatch.org/nh/salem/planning-board/2026-06-09/ #MeetingWatch #SalemNH
313/280 chars

X thread

1
The Salem Planning Board just approved a significant departure from parking standards at 291 South Broadway. Here is what residents need to know about the decision made on June 9. 🧵 #MeetingWatch #SalemNH
204/280
2
To approve the new fitness facility at Funhouse Plaza, the Board granted a permit to bypass the requirement for 408 parking spaces. The developer will instead provide only 236 spaces, based on the promise that the facility will use a 'scheduled class' model.
258/280
3
The decision wasn't without tension. Board members clashed over oversight: some argued for mandatory post-occupancy traffic studies to get real-world data, while others suggested making studies optional to avoid unnecessary costs.
230/280
4
Ultimately, the Board approved the project with 11 conditions, including a requirement for a third-party traffic review before occupancy. This decision prioritizes business flexibility over standard municipal parking requirements.
230/280
5
Why it matters: This sets a precedent for how Salem handles traffic and parking for large-scale commercial changes. If 'promises' of limited use replace strict code, the community bears the risk of increased congestion. https://meetingwatch.org/nh/salem/planning-board/2026-06-09/
243/280

Facebook — long form

At the June 9 Planning Board meeting, a decision was made regarding 291 South Broadway that could impact traffic and parking patterns for South Broadway residents for years to come.

The Board approved a 'change of use' for the Funhouse Plaza site, transforming an 18,000-square-foot retail space into an athletic performance facility. However, the approval comes with a significant concession: the developer was granted a permit to provide only 236 parking spaces, despite the city's standard requirement of 408 spaces.

The justification for this massive reduction is based on the applicant's representation that the facility will operate via scheduled classes rather than as an 'open membership' gym. This means the lower parking demand is predicated on how the business chooses to operate, rather than the physical capacity of the site.

The meeting saw heated debate among board members. Some argued that the city should rely on real-world data through mandatory post-occupancy traffic studies, while others pushed to make such studies optional to reduce costs. While the Board ultimately imposed 11 conditions to mitigate impact—including a third-party traffic review—the decision relies heavily on the business maintaining specific operational constraints to prevent local congestion. https://meetingwatch.org/nh/salem/planning-board/2026-06-09/ #MeetingWatch #SalemNH

Action ⁠items

Who owes what, by when.
Include hours of operation and prior approval notes on the final site plan.
Assigned: Funhouse Plaza LLC / Applicant · Due: Prior to final approval/construction
Install ADA-compliant signage and two additional ADA parking spaces.
Assigned: Funhouse Plaza LLC / Applicant · Due: Prior to occupancy
Add line striping for a crosswalk near the stop sign and reestablish any missing or diseased landscaping.
Assigned: Funhouse Plaza LLC / Applicant · Due: Prior to occupancy
Submit third-party traffic consultant (Steve Pernaut) approval/review to the town.
Assigned: Funhouse Plaza LLC / Applicant · Due: Prior to building permit/occupancy
Remove non-permitted temporary signage from the grass.
Assigned: Mr. Abbott · Due: Tomorrow

Member ⁠positions

3 issues · 0 explicit · 6 inferred · 1 unclear
A split vote in this meeting was recorded without naming the dissenter (e.g. a voice vote). Members whose individual vote could not be confirmed are marked UNCLEAR below — this is not the same as a “yes.” Named votes will be filled in if official minutes record them.
Joseph Feole
Chair
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP YES ~
Sean Lewis
Vice Chair
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP YES ~
Damon Norcross
Secretary
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP YES ~
Jim Harvey
Member
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP YES ~
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP YES
Post-Occupancy Traffic Study Conditions
Suggested making the traffic study optional to avoid unnecessary costs.
Chuck Saba
Member
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP YES ~
Paul Pelletier
Town Council Rep
Present
Funhouse Plaza LLC site plan completeness YES ~
Funhouse Plaza LLC change of use and CUP UNCLEAR
Expressed frustration regarding the readiness of staff and engineering reviews.
Robert Bryant
Town Council Rep (Alt)
Absent
Robert Gibbs
Alternate
Absent
Victor Helenic
Alternate
Absent
Jesse Jean
Alternate
Absent
Jeremy Guilbeault
Alternate
Absent

Positions marked ~ are inferred from context and may not reflect the member's explicitly stated position. UNCLEAR means the vote was split but the record did not name how this member voted — it is not a “yes.”

Support coverage

Creating this report cost ⁠real money.

MeetingWatch attended, transcribed, and analyzed this meeting on its own dime. If this work is valuable to you, chip in to keep covering Salem.

Report composed by gemma-4-26b, grok-4.3, grok-4.20-0309-reasoning, grok-4-fast · analyzed 2026-06-22.