Your area Not set — showing everywhere
Meeting report · Select Board
Creating this report cost real money. Help fund coverage →

Select Board — July 13, 2026

Legal grievances and tax base concerns dominate Bradford Select Board meeting

The meeting was marked by high-stakes public grievances involving legal allegations and disagreements over land use, though the board's voting remained steady.

Date Monday, July 13, 2026 Duration 2.3h Speakers 39 Public comments 4 Decisions 5 Lively

Questions about this meeting? ⁠Just ask.

Ask MeetingWatch answers from this meeting’s report, transcript, and records — with linked sources.

Summary AI-generated to surface controversy & community impact without bias — always verify against the actual meeting before relying on it.

Significant issues regarding town administration and long-term fiscal planning were at the forefront of the July 13 Select Board meeting.

A resident, Steve Patton, filed a formal grievance against Town Administrator Scott Butcher, alleging that Butcher violated his civil rights by attempting to trespass him during a tax deed auction. Patton also claims the town is attempting to disqualify his $6,000 winning bid in retaliation for his conduct. The Board has not taken disciplinary action, stating they are currently awaiting a legal opinion from counsel.

The discussion also turned to the former Cressy-Sims property. While there is interest in placing the land under a permanent conservation easement, residents argued that the town should instead consider mixed-use development to ensure residential growth and a stable tax base. Concerns were raised that failing to follow state statutes regarding the sale of town-owned real estate could lead to legal challenges. The Board has deferred this matter to the Planning Board.

Finally, community members raised concerns about the accuracy of public records related to Twigs Fire and the lack of a formal policy for handling anonymous complaints. The Board noted that no such policy currently exists but stated that one would be developed soon.

Jul 13, 2026 2.3h long 39 speakers 4 public comments 5 decisions Lively
Notable statements Drag to browse

“The town is at risk of a legal challenge if it indeed doesn't follow the guidelines of state law regarding the sale of town-owned real estate.”

— Michael Carter · Discussing the legal ramifications of putting the former Sims property under a conservation easement. ▶ 1:29:24

“If you are not willing to put your name on a complaint, I won't prosecute.”

— a board member · Responding to questions about the town's policy on anonymous complaints. ▶ 1:31:10

“We have sent everything to legal and we're waiting for a legal opinion.”

— a board member · Responding to the grievance regarding the tax deed auction and the potential disqualification of a bid. ▶ 1:40:32

“I think we need to behave nicer about it. And I've noticed we have a hard time doing that lately.”

— Devin Pendleton · Addressing the tension and tone of the meetings between the board and residents. ▶ 2:06:59
This meeting — choose a section

Public ⁠impact

Issues from this meeting with documented community impact.
What was discussed

Decision on whether to convert town-owned land to permanent conservation or allow residential growth.

What happened

The board deferred the discussion to the planning board.

Topics ⁠discussed

Each topic expands to quotes and full context.
Speakers: Beth Downs, a board member
What was discussed

The board reviewed and approved the minutes from the previous meeting.

What happened

The minutes were accepted as written.

Speakers: a resident, Beth Downs, a board member, Michael Carter
What was discussed

A resident raised concerns about logging activities affecting roads, leading to a discussion on road bonding and legal requirements.

What happened

The board suggested contacting a state investigator regarding logging infractions.

Speakers: the Tax Collector, Beth Downs, a board member
What was discussed

The Tax Collector provided an update on outstanding taxes, upcoming lien executions, and election responsibilities.

What happened

The Tax Collector presented the financial standing and election schedule.

Speakers: Chris Foss, a board member, Devin Pendleton
What was discussed

Chris Foss proposed forming an ad hoc committee to reimagine community spaces using the BACC and the former Norton property.

What happened

The board approved the formation of the ad hoc project team.

Speakers: the Independence Day Committee, Beth Downs, the Tax Collector
What was discussed

The committee reported on the success of the Fourth of July event and discussed future fundraising through merchandise.

What happened

The committee reported the event results and upcoming plans for more community engagement.

Speakers: a representative of the Conservation Commission, a board member
What was discussed

The Conservation Commission discussed a potential conservation easement on the Sherman Field property.

What happened

The board suggested waiting for formal maps and paperwork before formalizing an agreement.

Speakers: a resident
What was discussed

A resident expressed concerns regarding the lack of transparency in public records for Twigs Fire and requested a formal policy for handling anonymous complaints.

What happened

The board noted that no formal policy on anonymous complaints currently exists; a board member stated one would be developed soon.

Speakers: a resident, a board member, Michael Carter, the Town Administrator
What was discussed

A resident presented arguments for considering mixed-use development for the former Cressy Sims property rather than permanent conservation easement. Michael Carter addressed concerns regarding business operations at Twigs and expressed interest in the former Cresty/Sims property.

What happened

The board deferred the matter, suggesting the discussion be passed to the planning board. The speaker presented his position for the record.

Speakers: Steve Patton, a board member
What was discussed

A resident filed a formal grievance against the Town Administrator following an incident at a tax deed auction.

What happened

The board stated they have sent the matter to legal counsel and are awaiting a legal opinion.

Speakers: a staff member, a board member
What was discussed

A staff member reported on recent expenditures for swim supplies and proposed the purchase of a new grill for French's.

What happened

The board expressed no objection to the purchase of the grill.

Controversy & ⁠dissent

Where the board, the community, or the agenda diverged.

Potentially controversial issues

01

Tax Deed Auction Grievance

A resident filed a formal grievance alleging civil rights violations and retaliation by the Town Administrator regarding a property auction, which carries significant legal and administrative implications.
Board position: The board deferred a decision pending a legal opinion and declined to remove the Town Administrator from his duties.
high concern
02

Land Use of Former Cressy-Sims Property

There is a disagreement between advocates for permanent conservation easements and those advocating for mixed-use development to protect the town's tax base.
Board position: The board deferred the matter to the planning board.
medium concern

Community vs. board tension

Public ⁠comment

What residents said — verbatim, with timestamps.
3
Speakers
4
Comments
0
Addressed
3
Partial
1
Not addressed
Michael Carter
Partial
Michael addressed concerns regarding the Twigs Firewood property, noting that a DES inspection found zero violations but the town's public record lacks this closure. He also spoke about the former Cressy-Sims property, advocating for a balanced approach between conservation and planned residential growth to maintain the town's tax base. Key concern
Requesting correction of public records regarding Twigs, better transparency/minutes from the Conservation Commission, and considering multiple land-use options (including mixed-use) for the Cressy property rather than just a permanent easement.
Board response
The board noted they had no specific record of the DES letter in the property file and suggested passing the land-use questions to the planning board; they also discussed a potential policy for handling anonymous complaints.
The board addressed the record-keeping discrepancy and the complaint policy, but deferred the specific land-use and easement discussion regarding the Cressy property to the planning board.
Unidentified speaker
Not addressed
The speaker provided a written statement via email from Sonny Harris regarding the Cressy property. The letter argues that the property should be sold via open market bid to avoid legal risks and emphasizes the ecological importance of the land. Key concern
The property should be sold through a fair, competitive, and well-advertised open market bid rather than being encumbered by an easement.
Board response
The board acknowledged receipt of the email but stated that the property was not on the current agenda.
The board noted the email was received but did not engage with the substance of the request as it was not on the meeting agenda.
Steve Patton
Partial
Mr. Patton submitted a formal grievance regarding an auction held on June 27, alleging that the Town Administrator violated his civil rights by attempting to prevent him from discussing his interest in a property with other bidders. He also expressed concern that the town is withholding his winning bid on the property as retaliation. Key concern
Allegation of civil rights violation/retaliation by the Town Administrator and a request for immediate closure of the real estate transaction for which he is the winning bidder.
Board response
The board stated they are awaiting a legal opinion on the matter and refused to relieve the Town Administrator of his duties.
The board responded by stating the matter is currently with legal counsel and provided a definitive 'no' regarding his request to fire the administrator, but did not resolve the underlying transaction dispute.
Unidentified speaker
Partial
The speaker expressed concern regarding the tone of town meetings and the treatment of residents, suggesting that the board reacts poorly to unpleasant behavior. They also provided an update on Parks and Recreation expenses and requested a new grill for French's. Key concern
Improving the professional tone/conduct of the board toward residents and approval for a $500 grill purchase.
Board response
The board members engaged in a discussion about meeting conduct and approved the request for the new grill.
The board addressed the Parks and Rec request and discussed the conduct issue, but the discussion ended in disagreement rather than a resolution on how to change town culture.

Decisions ⁠logged

Every recorded vote, with timestamps and dissents.
Accept the minutes as written.
The board accepted the minutes from the previous meeting.
Approved
Approve the formation of an ad hoc project team led by Chris Foss with Devin Pendleton as liaison.
The board approved Chris Foss to lead the planning team for the community space project.
Approved
Accept tree removal quotes for Town Hall.
The board accepted the bid for tree removal at Town Hall.
Approved
Accept donations: $22,272 for Independence Day, $3,010 for 5K road race, and $100 for Brentford Scholarship Fund.
The board accepted donations under RSA 31:19.
Approved
Approval of the purchase of a new grill for French's.
The board agreed to the approximately $500 expenditure to replace a rusted grill.
Approved

Share ⁠this report

Drafts ready to post — click a block to copy, or use Share to post it.

X / Twitter — by angle

High-priority grievance regarding Town Administrator conduct and civil rights allegations.
At the July 13 Select Board meeting, a resident filed a formal grievance alleging the Town Administrator violated his civil rights and retaliated against him during a tax deed auction. The Board is awaiting a legal opinion before taking... https://meetingwatch.org/nh/bradford/select-board/2026-07-13/ #MeetingWatch
315/280 chars
Land use decision involving long-term fiscal impact and tax base stability.
Is Bradford's tax base being protected? During the 7/13 meeting, residents pushed for mixed-use development on the former Cressy-Sims property to ensure growth, rather than permanent conservation easements. The Board deferred the decision... https://meetingwatch.org/nh/bradford/select-board/2026-07-13/ #MeetingWatch
317/280 chars
Community concerns regarding record accuracy and complaint procedures.
Transparency alert: Residents raised concerns at the July 13 meeting regarding inaccurate public records for Twigs Fire and the lack of a formal policy for handling anonymous complaints. The Board says a policy is 'coming soon.'... https://meetingwatch.org/nh/bradford/select-board/2026-07-13/ #MeetingWatch
307/280 chars

X thread

1
Serious legal and administrative questions surfaced at the July 13 Select Board meeting. From allegations of civil rights violations to debates over the town's future tax base, here is what residents need to know. 🧵 #MeetingWatch #BradfordNH
241/280
2
First: A formal grievance was filed against Town Administrator Scott Butcher. A resident alleges Butcher attempted to trespass him during a tax deed auction and is now attempting to disqualify his $6,000 winning bid in retaliation. The Board has sent this to legal counsel.
273/280
3
Second: The future of the former Cressy-Sims property is in limbo. Residents argued for mixed-use development to maintain a healthy tax base, warning against permanent conservation easements that limit growth. The Board deferred this to the Planning Board.
256/280
4
Finally: Residents called for better transparency regarding Twigs Fire records and a formal policy for anonymous complaints to prevent harassment. The Board acknowledged the gap and stated a policy is under development. Stay tuned for updates. https://meetingwatch.org/nh/bradford/select-board/2026-07-13/
267/280

Facebook — long form

Significant issues regarding town administration and long-term fiscal planning were at the forefront of the July 13 Select Board meeting.

A resident, Steve Patton, filed a formal grievance against Town Administrator Scott Butcher, alleging that Butcher violated his civil rights by attempting to trespass him during a tax deed auction. Patton also claims the town is attempting to disqualify his $6,000 winning bid in retaliation for his conduct. The Board has not taken disciplinary action, stating they are currently awaiting a legal opinion from counsel.

The discussion also turned to the former Cressy-Sims property. While there is interest in placing the land under a permanent conservation easement, residents argued that the town should instead consider mixed-use development to ensure residential growth and a stable tax base. Concerns were raised that failing to follow state statutes regarding the sale of town-owned real estate could lead to legal challenges. The Board has deferred this matter to the Planning Board.

Finally, community members raised concerns about the accuracy of public records related to Twigs Fire and the lack of a formal policy for handling anonymous complaints. The Board noted that no such policy currently exists but stated that one would be developed soon. https://meetingwatch.org/nh/bradford/select-board/2026-07-13/ #MeetingWatch #BradfordNH

Action ⁠items

Who owes what, by when.
Serve as the select board liaison for the community space ad hoc planning team.
Assigned: Devin Pendleton
Prepare separate reports for the Independence Day fund and the roadway fund.
Assigned: The Tax Collector
Resubmit CIP request for the generator with updated numbers and include a placeholder for town hall maintenance/painting.
Assigned: Town Administrator
Develop a formal policy for handling complaints (including anonymous ones).
Assigned: Select Board
Order a new grill for French's and find volunteers for installation.
Assigned: a staff member

Member ⁠positions

6 issues · 0 explicit · 25 inferred
Present
Approval of Minutes YES ~
Community Space Project Proposal YES ~
Accept tree removal quotes for Town Hall YES ~
Accept donations YES ~
Approval of the purchase of a new grill for French's YES ~
Beth Downs
Selectman
Present
Approval of Minutes YES ~
Community Space Project Proposal YES ~
Accept tree removal quotes for Town Hall YES ~
Accept donations YES ~
Approval of the purchase of a new grill for French's YES ~
Devin Pendleton
Selectman
Present
Community Space Project Proposal YES
Appointed as the liaison for the project team.
Approval of Minutes YES ~
Accept tree removal quotes for Town Hall YES ~
Accept donations YES ~
Approval of the purchase of a new grill for French's YES ~

Positions marked ~ are inferred from context and may not reflect the member's explicitly stated position. UNCLEAR means the vote was split but the record did not name how this member voted — it is not a “yes.”

Support coverage

Creating this report cost ⁠real money.

MeetingWatch attended, transcribed, and analyzed this meeting on its own dime. If this work is valuable to you, chip in to keep covering Bradford.

Report composed by xai.grok-4.3, gemma-4-26b, grok-4.20-0309-non-reasoning, grok-4.20-0309-reasoning · analyzed 2026-08-01.