Meeting report · Select Board
Creating this report cost real money.
Help fund coverage →
Select Board — May 5, 2026
The meeting was elevated by serious allegations of legal contempt against the Town Manager and intense community pushback regarding a major redevelopment project.
Public impact
Issues from this meeting with documented community impact.
01
Zoning Bylaw Modernization
Broad changes to land use regulations, density, height, and housing policy. Affected: All property owners and developers in Plymouth
zoning change
02
Projected Fiscal Deficit
Potential for 'surgical cuts' to prevent a $14.8 million structural deficit by 2032. Affected: All taxpayers and municipal departments
budget cut
Decisions logged
Every recorded vote, with timestamps and dissents.
Motion to enter into Executive Session regarding real property.
Motion made by Ms. Iaquinto and seconded by Mr. Cohen.
Approved
Approval of administrative notes.
Motion made by Mr. Canty and seconded by Ms. Iaquinto to approve the list of administrative notes as a group.
Approved
Directing staff to continue the proactive pursuit of obtaining 10% subsidized housing inventory.
The board discussed the need to exceed the 10% threshold to maintain a permanent 'safe harbor' status following decennial census recalculations.
Previously approved by Select Board (April 21st)
Adjournment of the Planning Board meeting.
Motion made and seconded to adjourn the joint planning board session.
Approved
Adoption of enhanced monthly financial reporting.
The board adopted a model including total spend analysis, variance reporting, efficiency tracking, internal transfers, revenue tracking, and a section for future threats or opportunities.
Approved
Implementation of departmental budget presentation summits.
Beginning in November, department heads will present three budget scenarios: level service, level funded, and a 2% increase from FY27.
Approved
Topics discussed
Click a topic to expand quotes and full context.
▶ 23:03 Executive Session: Real Property Value
The Select Board entered executive session to discuss the purchase, exchange, lease, or value of real property regarding Landers Farm Road and the Symes House at 29 Manamitt Point Road.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 128:35 Airport Commission Contempt Complaint
Town Meeting Member Rich Cerkey provided a public comment regarding a Superior Court injunction and a contempt complaint filed by the Airport Commission against the Town Manager.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 130:11 Conceptual Redevelopment of 179 Court Street
A joint presentation by the Select Board and Planning Board regarding a proposed mixed-use senior living community (independent, assisted, and memory care) at the former Benny's Plaza site. Discussion focused on community integration, parking concerns, building height, and the impact on local residents.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 222:28 Zoning Bylaw Modernization Presentation
Assistant Town Manager Lauren Lind presented a concept for modernizing Plymouth's zoning bylaws, covering housekeeping (cleanup), policy changes (use regulations, dimensional standards), and subject areas like housing, economic development, and sustainability.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 220:41 Housing and Workforce Needs
Discussion regarding the critical need for varied housing price points in Plymouth, specifically emphasizing workforce housing for young families to prevent residents from being priced out of the community.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 232:23 Economic Development Strategy
The Town Manager suggested moving from a reactive to a proactive economic posture by engaging more frequently with state agencies like MassBio and MassDevelopment to recruit business opportunities.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 236:03 Budget Oversight and Fiscal Deficit
The board discussed the 'fiscal cliff' involving projected budget deficits and proposed new measures for enhanced monthly financial reporting and departmental review summits to mitigate future structural deficits.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 278:57 Town Manager's Report
Updates on municipal activities including the Freedom Memorial Cemetery groundbreaking, Community Health Improvement Plan, infrastructure projects, and a recent brush fire.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
▶ 288:11 Nuclear Power and Electricity Supply
Discussion on community concerns regarding nuclear power and the need for information on regional electricity generation and supply.
Speakers: Unidentified speaker
Controversy & dissent
Where the board, the community, or the agenda diverged.
Potentially controversial issues
01
Airport Commission Contempt Complaint
A Town Meeting Member alleged that the Town Manager is violating a Superior Court injunction and interfering with the Airport Commission's independence, creating a potential legal and governance crisis.
Board position: The board acknowledged the comment but did not take any substantive action or offer a defense/comment regarding the allegations against the Town Manager.
high concern
02
179 Court Street Redevelopment
A proposed mixed-use senior living project at the former Benny's Plaza site has sparked community debate regarding building height, traffic congestion, parking availability, and the actual affordability of the senior housing units.
Board position: The board and planning staff generally supported the project's goals for community integration and 'aging in place,' while directing developers to conduct further studies on traffic and parking.
high concern
03
Fiscal Deficit and Budgetary Management
The town faces a projected $14.8 million deficit by 2032, requiring discussions on 'surgical cuts' and more intensive departmental oversight to avoid major service reductions in the future.
Board position: The board approved enhanced financial reporting and departmental budget summits to proactively manage the 'fiscal cliff.'
medium concern
Community vs. board tension
Ready to share? AI-written accountability posts about this meeting's controversies.
View posts →
Action items
Who owes what, by when.
Conduct a traffic study and provide specific calculations for open space acreage.
Assigned: HYM Development / Nexco Group
Provide a detailed breakdown of parking spaces and the specific count for the senior living community.
Assigned: HYM Development / Nexco Group
Continue drafting a development agreement to be presented to the Select Board.
Assigned: Town Staff / Developer
Provide detailed parking numbers based on specific uses for evaluation by the board and neighborhood.
Assigned: Developers
Meet with the North Plymouth Steering Committee and the Affordable Housing Trust to discuss project parameters.
Assigned: Developers
Begin organizing and codifying zoning bylaws into an accessible online format.
Assigned: Planning Staff
Provide feedback and direction to staff regarding zoning priorities, trade-offs (density, height, parking), and policy implementations.
Assigned: Planning Board and Select Board
Implement enhanced monthly financial reporting and arrange for a representative from the ISO to present on electricity generation options.
Assigned: Town Manager (Derek) · Due: As soon as possible
Request budget presentations from department heads for the three specified scenarios (level service, level funded, and 2% increase).
Assigned: Town Staff · Due: Starting November
Issue an RFP for a new launch operator to ensure service is available for Memorial Day.
Assigned: Town Manager · Due: Before Memorial Day
Notable statements
This board needs to immediately take action to rein in this town manager. — Rich Cerkey · Commenting on the Airport Commission's contempt complaint against the Town Manager following a Superior Court injunction. ▶ 129:53
This is an opportunity to provide additional capacity for people who want to age in place in this community. — SPEAKER_01 (Assistant Town Manager) · Providing background on why the 179 Court Street redevelopment aligns with town planning goals. ▶ 157:00
I want to commend a proponent here because they're talking about doing this in a downtown area, in an area where you're not taking seniors and pushing them off to the side. — SPEAKER_04 (Planning Board Chair) · Supporting the location of the proposed senior living facility as a way to maintain community integration. ▶ 172:00
We have to change the way we think because what we've been doing, being reactive, hasn't worked for us. — Unidentified speaker · Discussing the need for proactive zoning and commercial development strategies rather than reacting to applications. ▶ 209:00
The core principle I believe should be that the planning board is most effective when it's not merely a permit processing body, but the town's elected land use policy board. — Unidentified speaker · Advocating for the Planning Board to shift from late-stage project reaction to early-stage rulemaking. ▶ 212:20
If we're not putting our money where our mouth is then we're just creating a never-ending campaign platform plank [regarding affordable housing]. — Unidentified speaker · Discussing the necessity of moving beyond political rhetoric to actual investment in workforce housing. ▶ 220:41
I'd like to see us invest more in workforce housing... we need price points that are far below what is market rate right now in Plymouth. — Unidentified speaker · Emphasizing the need for housing affordability for young families and residents at different life stages. ▶ 230:40
We're sitting here in a reactive posture, listening to [a developer's] idea. — Unidentified speaker · Critiquing the town's current approach to economic development and advocating for proactive engagement with state agencies. ▶ 232:23
I believe we need to make small surgical cuts now so that we don't have to make major slashes come fiscal year 29. — Unidentified speaker · Justifying the proposal for departmental review summits to address the projected $14.8 million deficit by 2032. ▶ 252:08
Public comment
What residents said — verbatim, with timestamps.
6
Total speakers
0
Addressed
5
Partial
1
Not addressed
Rich Cerkey
Not addressed
Mr. Cerkey discussed a Superior Court injunction regarding the management of the Plymouth airport and the independence of its commission. He alleged that the Town Manager's recent actions, such as interfering with finance functions and inquiring about leaseholders, constitute contempt of the court's order.
Key concern
The Town Manager is violating a court injunction by interfering with the Airport Commission and retaliating against its members.
Board responseThe Chairman thanked the speaker but did not offer a substantive response or action.
The board acknowledged the comment with a 'thank you' but did not address the allegations or discuss potential actions regarding the Town Manager.
Pat Adelman
Partial
Ms. Adelman noted that the 10% inclusionary housing requirement does not appear to apply to the senior living portion of the proposed development. She expressed concern regarding the affordability of the facility for local seniors.
Key concern
How affordable the senior living community will actually be for residents, given that it is excluded from inclusionary housing mandates.
Board responseThe Board Chair deferred the question, stating they would come back to the speaker later to answer.
While the board deferred the response during the public comment phase, the topic was discussed extensively later in the meeting by staff and board members.
Paul Blanchard
Partial
Mr. Blanchard expressed support for the project concept, noting that reusing a previously developed site is preferable to destroying forest land. However, he suggested that the retail buildings on Court Street should include more green space/setbacks to match the local character.
Key concern
The lack of green space/setbacks between the proposed retail buildings and the sidewalk on Court Street.
Board responseThe developer addressed the concept of the layout, but the board did not provide a specific ruling.
The developer responded to the general layout discussion, but no specific commitment to increasing setbacks was made by the board.
Ever Malagouti
Partial
As Vice Chair of the North Plymouth Steering Committee, he emphasized the need for thorough community engagement due to recent tensions regarding other developments. He also raised concerns about traffic from tourism and the potential displacement of neighbors' parking.
Key concern
The potential for increased traffic congestion and the displacement of existing residential parking near Nelson Street.
Board responseThe developer and board members engaged in a discussion regarding traffic studies and the commitment to parking on-site.
The developer acknowledged the concerns and stated they would conduct robust traffic and parking studies during the permitting process.
Paul Leonard
Partial
Mr. Leonard argued that a four-story building would be an overwhelming height for the immediate vicinity. He also expressed concern that the developer is underestimating the parking needs of residents and visitors to the rail trail.
Key concern
The excessive height of the building relative to the neighborhood and insufficient parking allotments.
Board responseThe developer responded by explaining the 'stepping' design of the building and the intention to conduct parking analyses.
The developer provided explanations for the design and parking strategy, but the resident's concerns regarding the 'overwhelming' nature of the height were not resolved.
Peter Balboni
Not addressed
As the owner of Piappi's, he expressed a desire to see the Benny's site redeveloped to remove an eyesore. He acknowledged concerns regarding traffic but expressed optimism about working with the town and developers.
Key concern
The revitalization of the site and managing the associated traffic concerns.
Board responseThe Chairman thanked him.
The speaker's comment was supportive, and the board simply acknowledged it.
Support coverage
Creating this report cost real money.
MeetingWatch attended, transcribed, and analyzed this meeting on its own dime. If this work is valuable to you, chip in to keep covering Plymouth.
Follow Plymouth
One email when a new report is published from the Select Board — or one weekly digest.
Report composed by
gemma-4-26b, claude-opus-4-7 · analyzed 2026-05-25.